Wednesday, 30 January 2008

BLP - Differentiate between employed and self-employed

Why employment status is important?

Many employment rights such as the right not to be unfairly dismissed, and the right to redundancy pay, rely on you being an employee.

Many employers take on self-employed workers in order to avoid employee rights and having to pay tax and national insurance for their employees.

It doesn’t matter how your employer refers to you as (employed or self-employed). What matters is what happens in practice, how you work? How much work you do? Do you use your own tools or the employer provides them?

The main differences:

Employee

Has a contract of service (expressly or implied).

Existence of a maximum hours threshold and minimum wage.

including unfair dismissal, redundancy and maternity rights - includes all those rights enjoyed by workers

Self-Employed

A person in business on their own account.

Have fewer rights except those they negotiated for themselves.

Certain rights in respect of trade unions and under the Human Rights Act only.


The courts have created a test to assess whether a worker is employed or self-employed:

  • Control – the greater the control exercised by an employers over the manner in which its workers carry out their duties the more likely they are to be employees.
  • Mutuality of obligation to provide and to do work – employers are obliged to offer their employees work and employees are obliged to do it, so the greater the obligation the more likely that they are employees.
  • Substitution – employees are usually obligated to carry out their duties personally so If the worker can send along a “stand-in” then they are more likely to be self-employed.

BLP - Choosing a business name

A client needs to consider:

  • Any regulatory regime (if any) that applies to the name chosen &
  • Whether the name chosen be legally protected.

Regulatory regime

Different regimes for incorporated businesses (e.g. companies & LLP) and unincorporated business (partnerships and sole traders).

Incorporated businesses (Companies & LLP)

Neither limited companies nor LLP can be registered (i.e. cannot form) unless the name chosen by their founders is approved by Registrar of Companies. To get that approval the name must not be:

  • An existing name on the index, maintained by the Registrar of Companies.
  • A name whose use would be a criminal offence.
  • A name which is offensive.
  • A name which is misleading.
  • A name which would suggest a link with HM Government.
  • Nor contain any prescribed words without the consent of the relevant regulatory body (Company & business Names Regulations 1981 –SI 1981/1865).

See also CA 85 (ss25-29 & 348-351) & Limited Liability Partnership Act 2000.

Unincorporated businesses (Partnerships & Sole Traders)

As long as a sole trader or Partnership choose to trade under their own name(s) then no regulations apply. Because everyone transacting with such a business knows the identity of those who run the business (s1 Business Names Act 1985).

If however they wish to use a “business or trading name” would mean that ss2-11 of the Business Names Act 1985 would need to be complied with, i.e. so that the actual surnames of those running the business are disclosed on all correspondences (invoices) so that creditors and all third parties know who they are dealing with.

The use of any prescribed names in the business name requires permission of the relevant specified body (see Company and Business Names Regulations 1981 for a full list of words and the appropriate body).

A corporate body wishing to trade under a business name would be required to comply with Business Names Act s1(1)(c). Which would mean the corporate body’s registered name would have to be disclosed on all stationary etc. Again so that the creditor knows who they are dealing with.

HOWEVER AFTER 1ST OCTOBER 2008 CORPORATE NAMES WILL BE DEALT WITH UNDER PART 5 OF CA 06 WHILST BUSINESS NAMES WILL BE DEALT WITH UNDER PART 41.

Wednesday, 23 January 2008

BLP- Removal of Director

Table A article 81 deals with this and provides that the office of director will be vacated in a number of circumstances:

  1. He ceases to be a director by virtue of … the act or prohibited by law from being a director.
  2. He becomes bankrupt.
  3. He resigns his office by notice to the company.
  4. He shall for more than six consecutive months have been absent without permission of the directors from meetings of directors held during that period and the directors resolve that his office be vacated (taking article 11+12 into account).

It is therefore quite common for companies to supplement these provisions by giving the directors/members powers to remove in a wider range for circumstances.


Removal of director by members

Companies shall also be bound by s168 CA 06.; giving members power to remove a director by ordinary resolution at a meeting subject to a directors right to protest under s169 CA 06 (not that it’ll make a difference). Special notice to the company will be required (s312 CA 06) of at least 28 days. Therefore you can’t use short notice.

As a director is also a member, he may also have the benefit of what is known as a “Bushell v Faith” clause in the company’s articles (article 10). This gives the members enhanced voting rights on a motion to remove a director where he/she has less than 50% of the shares in the company.

Removal from Executive office

If the director is an executive then under Table A article 84 removal from the board would also terminate this role and the directors employment with immediate effect. However this can have employment law consequences as termination of an employment contract without notice may result in having to pay compensation. Unless the director has been guilty of very serious misconduct.

BLP - Appointment of a Director

S154 CA 06 requires every private company to have at least one director, the first being appointed through the signing and submission of Form 10. There after appointment is governed by a company’s Articles (table A Articles 78-79).

78 …a company may by ordinary resolution appoint a person who is willing to act as a director either to fill a vacancy or as an additional director…

79 The directors may appoint a person willing to act as a director, provided that the appointment does not exceed the maximum number of directors in accordance with the articles…

Once a new director has been appointed then the Registrar of Companies must also be informed using the appropriate Form (288(a)). However a director may also wish to be appointed to an executive role within the company (Table A article 84).

Executive directors should be issued with an employment contract (sometimes referred to as a “service agreement” and defined as a “Service contract” in s277 CA 06) with the company. If they do then it’s important to ensure that s188-189 and 228 CA 06 are complied with:

  • S188 CA 06 provides where the term of a directors employment is or longer than two years then the company may not agree to such a provision unless it has been approved by a resolution of members of the company.
  • S189 CA 06 states where s188 is contravened then the provision in the contract as to duration will be void and the contract will instead be terminable on “reasonable notice”.
  • S228 states that a copy of all current directors service contracts (or a memoranda of their main terms) must be kept at the company’s registered office (or another authorised place) and must be retained for at least one year after termination.

Sunday, 6 January 2008

Civil Lit - Commencing a Claim

All attempts to negotiate have so far failed and all pre-action requirements have been met. The C solicitor will fill out a claim form (N1) and file it at the court.

The Date the claim was commenced?

This is neither the date the form was completed and signed or the date it is sent. But the date of issue or commencement is the date stamped on the form. Make sure the issue date is within the Limitation period.

Which court to use?

In order to fill the claim form you need to decide which court you are using. Decide between the High Court and the County Court paying attention to geographical issues.
In deciding between the two consider: the cause of the action, its value and the nature of the case (PD 7).

  • Cause of Action: specialist cases (J.review & Human Rights) tend to go to the High Court. Breach of contract and negligence claims can be begun in either the High Court or the county Court so following the general presumption, the county court should generally be used unless there is another reason to use the High Court.
  • The value of the claim: Or the amount the claimant reasonably expects to get. The county court usually has unlimited financial jurisdiction subject to other factors. Therefore a claim for any amount can be begun here. The High Court however is limited to:
    1. PI claims (as defined in CPR 2.3 (1)) with a value of £50,000 or more.
    2. Other claims with a value of more than £15,000.
  • The nature of the case will include:
    1. The financial value of the case
    2. The complexity of the facts
    3. The importance of the outcome to the general public.


Civil Lit - Early Action and Investigation

Pre-Action Protocol

Pre-Action Protocol requires a free flow of information between parties.

Obtain Witness Evidence – With the help of your client and using a police accident report identify all people who were witnesses in the case. Able to give evidence on any aspect, covering liability or quantum (amount of damage). But you need not use all witnesses. If you do interview one of the other sides witnesses, as a professional curtsey you should inform them in advance (CPR Rule 11, guidance point 16). Explaining witnesses maybe required to come to court to give evidence and roughly when that could be.

Obtaining Records (documents)

  • Police Accidence reporter
  • Certificate of conviction
  • Accident report book
  • Photographs
  • Contract
  • Quantum/liability

PI protocol applies to all clams:

  1. C sends two copies of a letter of claim containing specified information.
  2. D should reply within 21 calendar days.
  3. D has three months from the date of acknowledgement to investigate and respond in detail to the claim.
  4. If liability is denied the defendant discloses specified documents to the C.
  5. C sends a schedule of special damages to the D.
  6. An expert is agreed where appropriate.
  7. Parties consider some form of alternative dispute resolution.

The Letter of Claim acts as a warning letter, sent by the C. The letter sets out the nature of the claim and the facts upon which it is based.

Contents of the letter:

  • As soon as there is enough information/evidence to commence a claim a letter of claim should be issued.
  • Contain a summery of the facts and nature of injuries/financial loss.
  • Whether the case is funded by a conditional fee on success/ or an insurance premium.
  • A copy of the letter sent to the defendant’s insurer. If unknown either request this information from the D or send a copy of the letter to the D to forward to his insurer.
  • Sufficient information given for D solicitor to investigate the claim
  • The letter should ask for an acknowledgement within 21 days of the date of posting, failing which a claim maybe commenced.
  • After letter of claim a schedule of special damages with supporting documents should be sent.

Civil Lit - Potential Claimant

Solicitor Consult

First Interview

1. Who is the Claimant and Defendant?

2. What does the claimant want? Damages, injunction?

Special Damages – are all p[ast quantifiable losses to date (Medical, Damage to property, Travel expenses)

General Damages – all other losses (pain, suffering and loss of amenity).

The limitation period will start to run when the cause for action comes into existence i.e. when the contract is breached:

Basic Contract Case

6 years from breach

Tort Cases

6 years from cause

Personal Injury

3 Years from the date

Defamation

1 year from the publication

Under s33 of the Limitation Act the court has a discretion to extend the limitation period in personal injury cases.

3. Professional conduct issues

4. General Legal Advice? Is it viable?

5. Funding/cost

  • Private payment
  • Conditonal fee agreement
  • Community legal Services funding
  • Before the event insurance
  • Sponsership
  • Pro Bono

6. What the client must be told (Code 2).

  • All costs must be given in writing and basis of firmcharges.
  • Alternative funding.
  • What happens if they loose.